35 Followers
107 Following
Lenaribka

Lenaribka

"We should read to give our souls a chance to luxuriate."

 

~Henry Miller

Currently reading

Operation Rubikon
Andreas Pflüger, Merlau, Günter
The Future Won't Be Long
Jarett Kobek
A Short History of Nearly Everything
William Roberts, Bill Bryson
The Power of One
Humphrey Bower, Bryce Courtenay
The Romanov Mission
Robert Jackson
Goliath: A Thriller
Shawn Corridan, Gary Waid
Last Days of Summer
Steve Kluger
And the Band Played On
Randy Shilts, Victor Bevine

Listening to Dust

Listening to Dust - Brandon Shire
Rounded up to 3 stars.



I managed to finish it and now I can say that it was the most depressing and helpless book I have ever read. I would even warn you, don't read it if you suffer from depression. It could be then really dangerous.

Though I prefer books with a HEA, I'm not someone who specifically avoids books without a good ending.
I would never judge against a book because of the ending. I like an ending that fits the book.
I like the books that even in spite of unhappy ending, despite being sad are emotional, heart-warming, touching but NOT in a depressing way. The most important thing - they have to give a reader at least a slight glimmer of hope.

If you're Okay with the only "positive" message of the book
YOU CAN HATE DEEP, BUT LOVE IS EVEN DEEPER.

then you can read it.

This book left me with a blank icy stare after reading it and with a much emotional distress and pain, helpless, powerless, sorrowful, numb with grief. This story broke my heart. It is deeply pessimistic.

It is not JUST the ending - the whole story is enduring torture.
But I have to confess, a very well written one.

Sorry, I need a hope in my books.

My conclusion:
The writing- 5 stars, the story-1 star.



I know I'm in the minority, but there are readers who share my opinion about the book.
Todd expressed exactly my thoughts. Warning: it contains spoilers.